Sophie Golub
Editor-in-Chief
After over five years in captivity, it was announced on Tuesday, October 11 that abducted Israel Defense Forces soldier Gilad Shalit will be released in a prisoner exchange deal between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Hamas. According to Hamas leader Khaled Meshal, over 1000 Hamas prisoners will be released in two separate stages in exchange for Shalit, which will take place within the next two months.
In June 2006, militants in the Gaza Strip captured a nineteen-year-old Shalit during a cross-border raid. The deal comes after the conclusion of several failed negotiations between the two parties over the past five years to release the young soldier.
Shalit will be officially released on Tuesday, October 18, as well as 477 prisoners. The list of prisoners is now available to the public, citing 315 as serving life sentences and 27 as female Palestinian prisoners.
David Median, head of Shalit negotiations, led an Israeli delegation in Cairo to negotiate a possible deal. Egyptian intelligence chief General Murad Muwafi and his aides mediated the deal between Median and Ahmed Al-Jabari, chief of Hamas’ military wing.
A secret emergency meeting was called for Tuesday, October 11, to approve the deal, which passed by a 26-3 vote. Netanyahu explained to reporters a “window of opportunity” opened up and that he had to act fast or risk never freeing Shalit.
Abu Obeida, spokesperson for Hamas’ military wing, confirmed the prisoner exchange deal.
Although the release is met with skepticism and fear by many, most are celebrating the release of Shalit and the conclusion of a multi-year national trauma.
Rachel Zucker • Oct 25, 2011 at 7:42 am
Gilad became a symbol. A symbol that all mothers in Israel related to and wanted set free. Why would anyone want to be kept in captivity, under the harm of Hamas and without any connection to the outside world. I believe that the setting free of GIlad Shalit was a remarkable transaction, however I havent yet concluded if it was worth it. Setting free 1027 terrorists for one man doesnt seem like a fair trade. Many of those terrorists have killed more than one man and have said that they wouldnt hesitate to do more terrorist attacks before they were imprisoned. Though Gilad is set free, it allows Israel to show their emotional side, however that is both a curse and a blessing. It shows that they have a heart, but now it gives room for other countries to take advantage of them. But until we see the aftermath of the trade, let us be joyous that we have a symbol of survival amongst us. !עמ ישראל חי
Nicole Nourian • Oct 24, 2011 at 7:31 pm
Gilad Shalit has brought more to Israel, than he ever could imagine. For a young boy taking such a risk in sacrificing his own life, is a true love for Israel. I think that Gilad Shalit’s homecoming brings a lot of questions, but hope to the Jewish people. What I believe is that Hamass now thinks that kidnapping will enable them to take advantage over Israel because they know their policy of “no soldier left behind.” One common question is if it was right to exchange so many prisoners of Hamsas (1,027) for one soldier, Gilad Shalit. I believe that if anyone was in Gilad Shalit’s parents shoes, they would wan their son back no matter what. This is something people should think about before they start to grumble over the deal Hammas made with Israel. Also, many ask “what about all those prisoners who killed other israeli children? What about their parents?” When Israel has a chance, even if it is so little, to bring back a soldier home, they will go above and beyond to get them back. It is not as if they wanted to let all these prisoners let go, but when they see they have the opportunity to get this israeli soldier out of suffering, they don’t question the deal. Gilad Shalit over the years has inspired many to see the love of Israel, including me in many ways. It has only made my love and respect for Israel much greater. Israel, Gilad Shalit, and his inspiring parents have shown that with a great amount of hope, you can succeed in what you do. Although its been much more longer than anyone wanted it to be, words cannot describe my happiness, and joy towards Gilad’s homecoming and all of Israel.
Deeba Danesh • Oct 23, 2011 at 2:43 pm
I believe that this is a very controversial topic since Israel is not like America. America has a no negotiation policy with terrorists, when Israel is made a deal to release 1027 terrorists for Gilad.
Positive view of having our solider come home: One mad is equivalent to one world. Gilad is an example of how far Israel will go to get you back since when you are enrolled in the army you are promised with the fact that Israel will do anything in its power to get you back, even if it is your remains. No one is left behind or forgotten.
Negative view of making this deal: This shows how far Israel will go, so now Hamas can use this to their advantage when they next attack or kidnap someone. is it fair to those that have lost their lives from these 1027 terrorists? these terrorists most probably will go back to the actions that have landed them into prison.
To try to think of another solution that the population would agree on would be close to impossible since no matter what, the price of one soul is impossible to “calculate”. Israel had made the right dession to bring back our soldier but i truly am unable to bring my self to say that Israel had made the right deal.
Gilad is a symbol of Israel’s devotion and love towards the men and woman that fight for our state. This is not the first time that Israel has released prisoners, this is actually the fourths time. Israel has even released 400 some terrorists for two remains of soldiers and one alive.
israel does anything for their soldiers and that is why i am truly glad to support and be apart of Israel.
Ali Deutsch • Oct 23, 2011 at 1:19 pm
Gilad Shalit is symbolic of how Israel treats every person as an individual and does not rest until they are home. Israel has always been a country about sustaining as many lives as possible, with great risks that have been taken by the army. Each soldier shows the will of giving up their lives for their country and it’s peaceful existence, but Israel cherishes every life as it can change the world. This might not have been clear to people in the Diaspora before, being shown biased opinions against the Israeli army, who proceed to take risky operations against terrorism. These people are now shown that Israel sticks together and will do everything to return people home, dead or alive in peace.
Leayam Meiri • Oct 21, 2011 at 7:57 pm
I think that Gilad Shalit’s captivity release was a great deal for all the Jewish people around the world. Gilad’s captivity, was a topic for everyone during lessons about Israel and about the Israeli Army Force. Israel is a strong nation that fights for all over their soldiers, and their promise is that all of their soldiers will leave looking like a soldier, and return home safely like a soldier. When a soldier in the Israeli Army gets lost, dies, or gets injured, it is ultimately the Armys’ responsibility to help save or pretect that issue. Israel cares about each and every one of their soldiers, and therefore they did not stop fighting for Gilad Shalit. Besides the fact that the army did not stop fighting for Gilad, his parents, Noam and Aviva, continued putting out his name and supporting for Gilad. I think that with both the help of his friends, parents, and army, that is the reason this incredible soldier returned home. I am very proud of Israel for accepting this deal and showing that one soldier is more important than over 1,000 terrorists that belong to HAMAS. Gilad shalit’s freedom is making our nation feel free- spirited and also free.
Maya Mashiach • Oct 21, 2011 at 5:32 pm
In Israel, practically everyone knows each other because it is a small and tightly bound country. I know this because even when I went to visit after 4 years, so many people knew me. Imagine that all these people know and care for Gilad Shalit and believe that he should be released. Israel believes that if they have the choice to release anyone they possibly can, then they will do it. They care for each individual citizen of Israel because there are so little of us, Jews, that it is so important to keep as many as possible safe and healthy.
This situation with Gilad brings a lot of attention to the fact that other families dealt with a relative, sibling, or son/daughter were captured and were never kept track of. It is hard on them knowing that a family got this attention, but they brought to themselves. They tried their hardest by making Gilad Shalit’s capture public and that’s what really helped to get him home safely.
Today, Gilad is a symbol of hope for the country and hope will stay forever.
Alex Shamash • Oct 19, 2011 at 11:02 am
Gilad Shalit being released has brought up many emotions such as happiness, disappointment, anger, and bewilderment. How can one man be worth 1,027 terrorists who killed tons of innocent Israeli people and vowed to keep on killing until the day they die? Let us remember that Israel has a no man left behind policy, but it also has a no negotiation with terrorists policy. How can they contradict one policy but follow the other? Gilad Shalit’s trade is only just beginning to release the domino effect on everyone. He was released, which affected Israel and brought hope and happiness, but 1,027 terrorists were released, which brought on anger and confusion. How is Gilad Shalit going to feel when (G-d forbid) one of those terrorists kills an innocent person? Is Gilad going to feel responsible? How are the families of the victim going to feel, not just about the death, but about how it is Gilad that aided to the release of these people? I think that the deal was not a fair trade at all, and in fact can cause many problems. Israel proving to the world that they will do anything to get just one soldier back opens a lot of windows of opportunity to other terrorists groups to kidnap other Israelis and get what they want/take advantage of Israel. Gilad Shalit being released is fantastic, but there are a lot of other people negatively affected by the trade to get him back.
Milana BD • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:51 pm
The event of Gilad Shalit’s return is one marked with great joy and great pain. I cannot fathom the range of emotions exhibited in Israel at this time, from the great happiness and celebration of Gilad’s family to the sorrow of families of terror victims.
Politically, this is also a great victory and a great loss. It is a victory for Israel because his return represents the return of morals and emotion into the political system. It is also a great loss that so many horrible people are allowed to walk free with the option to strike again.
I personally struggled with the notion that so many terrorists are being exchanged for one life, but a point that Arielle made really helped change my outlook on the issue. She said (and I am paraphrasing) that Israel makes a promise to its citizens when they enlist in the army that the nation will do everything in its power to bring them home, dead or alive. She continued to say that if Israel did not do everything in her power to save Gilad, future soldiers would not be able to trust in Israel’s promise.
Gilad serves as a symbol for the Israeli nation and the entire Jewish people. This tragic event helped bring to light how great of a community the Jewish people is nationwide and how every life matters. Gilad could have been anyone’s brother, cousin, friend. He lost some of the most prized years of one’s life, and I think Israel owed him the right to at least live out the rest of his life.
To conclude, I just want to say that I recognize the complexity of the issue. I trust that Israeli officials thought long and hard about this issue and examined the multitude of implications this decision will have. I think they made a strategic and wise decision, just as they always do, and I trust in Israel’s judgement.
Julia Cohen • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:48 pm
I think that this is a time of hope and to be thankful that Gilad is home safe after enduring five and halk years of being held captive. However, this is also a time for everyone to be cautious because Israel has just freed thousands of terrorist that are potentially dangerous for Israel and the Jewish people. Gilad’s story is very heart-warming and reassuring to know that one’s homeland is willing to go to great extents for one person. The state of Israel values every person in it and promises to do all it can to keep everyone safe. This idea of Israel doing everything they can to free one human being, no matter the circumstance, may seem drastic to some people, but Gilad is now more than a person to Israel. He is symbol of hope and life. Additionally, Gilad is a symbol of reassurance to the citizens of Israel because they are now aware how important they are to the state. They can now feel confident that Israel deeply cares for them and will use everything at its disposal to keep their safety. Gilad will be always remembered by the way he and his situation affected Israel.
Joel Seligman • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:39 pm
While this deal does raise eyebrows about what this says about the ability of Hamas to manipulate the Kneset into making a less than satisfactory deal in regards to the amount of terrorists being released, it also enlightens many great differences between Israel and the world. There is no other country in the world that would embrace the symbolism of Gilad Shalit and the message his story sends that all soldiers need to eventually find their way back home to Israel. There is no such public influence on such a position in any other country except Israel. Any stable country’s military, draft (Israel) or non draft, would want this. This is true about America too. There are stories of US army bravery like Black Hawk Down. The key difference is that the mentality of the population of Israel is much more unified in bringing everyone home, whereas in America, most of the population seems distanced from the armed forces except on special occasions. This distinction is part of what makes the Israeli people great.
Avi Sholkoff • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:15 pm
Wow. 1027 terrorists for one soldier. Anyone can look at this trade, and they can think it is crazy. To the Jewish community it is not. It is everyone’s son returning home. Gilad Shalit can now see his family and friends for the first time in 5 years. I am so happy for him. I cannot imagine having to be in solitary confinement for 5 years and not having contact with the outside world. This trade also demonstrates that Israel values life. I am extremely proud of Israel for this trade, and hope it sends a message that Israel values life, and will do anything to bring back their soldiers!
Shelby Peris • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:13 pm
Gilad Shalit was held by Hamas in captivity for 5 and a half years. On october 18th 2011, he was released and brought back to Israel. To me, I believe that it is great that Gilad was sent home, and it brings pride to all Jews. I think him being held captive was an awful situation, but hope is all restored for him and his family. In addition, Israel believes that one person is worth the world. The knowledge of one person being free and with pride in their eyes means everything for the Jewish people. Israel cannot stand to think about one of their important people not believing they have another day to live or even another second. They want every Jew to be free and full on confidence. The Jewish people will do anything to help their community and save their ‘brothers’. They will never leave anyone behind, just like Gilad Shalit. The Jewish people released 1000 terrorists to free 1 Jew. Thats how devoted our people are.
Sarah Weitzman • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:12 pm
Welcome home Gilad Shalit! I cannot express the amount of joy that I have for the return of Gilad Shalit to his family, friends, and Israel. This calls for a time of excitement and happiness, yet, still, I have some doubts about the exchange. While I believe in the importance of pikuach nefesh, valuing one’s life, and see Gilad’s captivity as utter evil and terrorism, I am still very concerned about the 1,027 terrorists that were exchanged for his release. Although this demonstrates the value that Israel places in each one of its soldier’s lives, it also may instill fear in the Israeli people as these terrorists are now free to commit more horrible crimes in Israel. In addition, the exchange may in fact lead to more kidnappings since Hamas might see this as a means to release more of their terrorists from Israeli jails. Still, Gilad Shalit has become a symbol for the hope of the Israeli people and the survival of the State of Israel. His release illustrates the perseverance of Israelis and Jews all around the world.
Roy Ziv • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:11 pm
After 5 long years Gilad Shalit has finally come home. Gilad represents a symbol of hope for our country to show that we should never give up. After being held in captivity by enemy control for around 2000 days, has he finally been able to set foot on Israeli soil. Although I am very happy for Gilad Shalit finally coming home, I fear about what is to come in the future if other Israeli soldiers will become captured. I have heard about Hamas terrorists that are being trained not to kill Israeli soldiers, but instead to try and wound them and then capture them. If more Israeli soldiers become captured will Israel still continue its strong policy of no man left behind? Will they allow so much time to go by before they make a decision just as what happened with Gilad Shalit? Although it is very difficult to discuss the future, I am still very happy for the return and Gilad Shalit and I wish him the best.
Ariel Dankner • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:10 pm
After 5 and a half years of waiting, Jews and Israelis across the globe have finally received the exciting news of Gilad Shalit’s return to Israel. The decision, influenced by a genuine love for the people of Israel, provides a sense of security and reassurance to all the soldiers that will fight to defend Israel in the future. Israel has kept her promise to do everything in her power to bring a soldier home (whether he be dead or alive), and for this we should celebrate Gilad’s return. But while doing so, it is important to recognize the emotional impact this significant event in history has on the families who have been affected by the 1000 terrorists who are now being released. A 25 year old man, for instance, lost his entire family, mother, father, sister, and brother, to a terrorist attack in Israel. Now his family’s murderer is being released, and he has no control over the situation. Another man, in his late 30’s, or early 40’s, lost his sister to a terrorist attack in a small Café in Israel. His sister’s murderer is also being set free. Is it truly just that the murderers of hundreds, even thousands of lives be released on account of one life? Though this matter should be recognized and considered, I still believe the decision was absolutely just. What the terrorists have done, or the people they killed, happened in the past. What they may do, or the people they may or may not hurt later, is in the future. Gilad Shalit is alive right now, today. And today, we must celebrate the end of his, his family’s, his friends’ suffering.
Daphna Fischel • Oct 18, 2011 at 8:25 pm
Finally Gilad is home! After five and a half years he has been tortured and lived in a way most of us can’t even imagine. When he was first evaluated for joining the army, he wasn’t forced to fight. He choose to fight for his country. He was a dedicated solider who didn’t deserve anything that happened to him. Now he is safe at home, and this shows how Judaism truly values a single persons life and will not leave anyone behind. However, we have given back 1,027 terrorists who can come back and kidnap or murder more Israeli citizens or soldiers. It is very hard to know whether we should make our decision based on statistics or our beliefs, and we choose to go with our beliefs and save a soul. At first I thought Israel shouldn’t have given the terrorists back because it wasn’t worth it for just one soldier. However, after seeing Gilad come back home and meeting real people for the first time in 5 and a half years, I could feel nothing but pure happiness for him and our community. Our prayers have now been heard and answered.
Jordan Rosenbloom • Oct 18, 2011 at 8:13 pm
Finally, after 5 and a half years in captivity, Gilad Shalit is home. It may just be a negotiation to some of us, but to others it was faith and believing that he would eventually return home that got him back. However, people question if the deal to get Gilad back was a fair one. On the one hand, Israel does have a no soldier left behind policy, and us as Jews value life more that anything. On the other hand, exchanging Gilad for 1027 terrorists might not have been so good for the Israeli soldiers and families. These terrorists released killed many Israeli soldiers and citizens and by letting them free, we are giving them that opportunity once again. To some, 1027 for 1 just doesn’t look right. I believe that this was a fair trade because even though the exchange of people was completely disproportional, Gilad meant a lot to the Israeli people and Israel as a country had a duty to bring him home. I wish Gilad an easy mental recovery from the hardships he had to go through and I hope that he can soon live a normal life just like he did before he was captured.
Serena Wolman • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:53 pm
Gilad Shalit being freed has really defined our community. It proves that Israel will always stand up for what they believe in and that we are determined. We never leave a man behind and we will always fight hard to stick to our intentions. Even though we had to give a great amount of terrorists back to Palestine, i believe that Gilad Shalit over powers the whole argument and controversy. I was able to feel so much relief and joy from all the way from across the world from his friends and family, and i cant even begin to feel the pain of his parents and family when he was held hostage. Even though the controversy was very difficult to fight and overcome, i believe that Gilad deserved to come home.
Charlene Niku • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:53 pm
We’ve been waiting for this day for over 5 years! The time has finally come where Gilad Shalit can go see his family after being in captivity for such a long time. The fact that the Jewish people value life, even just one life, so much that they would risk freeing a thousand prisoners makes me so proud to be one myself. I remember seeing Noam Shalit, Gilad’s father when visiting Israel. I felt the pain I could see in his eyes and could only imagine dealing with the pain he went through for the past five years. Yesterday I even coincidentally saw a sticker on my desk that said “Gilad is still alive” and thought to myself, wow, the Jews never gave up hope. Our national anthem, Hatikva is a great song especially for this situation. Although I am concerned of the risks of freeing so many terrorists, I am happy that the Israeli government was finally able to negotiate and free Gilad. Seeing the video made me feel so proud to be a Jew and to see a soldier of Israel free. I hope that he will be able to live a full life full of happiness, health, and security! Welcome back, Gilad!!
Eytan Wallace • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:49 pm
Very nicely written Sophie! I am still undecided about this issue. First let me start off with the media’s coverage. Not once did I hear someone on the media say that Israel is releasing “terrorists”, rather they ALL said “Prisoners”. These people released are responsible for the deaths of hundreds if not thousands of people. Of course they should be known as “terrorists”! No brainer! Now, to Gilad himself, I am very happy he came back. He can now be celebrating with his family, friends, and the entire state of Israel. I am happy for him, but I mourn for those who will die in the future because of these terrorist. What I mean by this is that I know, not think, but know that many will be hurt if not killed by these terrorists in the years to come.One can now see why I am still divided on this issue but I hope the best will occur for Israel out of this. Thank you.
Joel Seligman • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:44 pm
While I agree with what you are saying about them being terrorists, there is a reason for it. Because terrorists are “political ideologists” and kill and do the evil things they do to try to make a political point (like the IRA and other “revolutionary groups”), governments try to eliminate the political aspect of their crimes and make them seem as common criminals so as to break the political spirit by not allowing them to be recognized as a political factor. While you and I call them terrorists, for the sake of suppressing their cause, governments generally do not refer to them as terrorists.
Ariel Bina • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:20 pm
Gilad Shalit definitely deserved to be released from captivity. Truthfully, any one would after five and a half years of barley seeing the outside world at all. It is really sickening to me that such a tragedy would occur. I can’t begin to fathom how Gilad Shalit feels. After what he has gone through, God knows how long it will take him to recover. The saddest part is Gilad will never be the same. Even though every day people change because of the new experiences they come across, most of those experiences cannot be compared to the trauma this brave soldier has been through.When I saw Gilad Shalit this morning, I felt two different things, happiness but also sadness. Gilad was very skinny and pale which are signs of bad treatment. It showed that he hadn’t seen the sun for the longest time. But when the terrorist were being released, it really showed that they were all well fed and treated with care because all of them looked healthy. It doesn’t seem fair that this is the case but when we are dealing with people who don’t value life, there is really no upside. This day is truly a day of mixed emotions. On one end I am relived that Gilad is finally home but on the other I am worried about how many more lives those 1,027 criminals will take. Israel values every life, “no man is ever left behind”. But in my opinion in the long run more lives will be taken from us because those terrorist who are being released are capable of taking many more lives than just one. I also feel some sympathy to the families who lost their loved ones because these criminals took their lives. It’s hard to imagine how they feel when the man or woman who killed they loved one walks out of prison a free person. In the end of the day, it is really difficult to figure out how to feel about this situation.
Daniel Shaby • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:18 pm
Finally Gilad Shalit is home !!!
After five years that Gilad Shalit has been imprisoned, it’s about time he is being released! This shows that Israel cares about many people living in Israel especially the people who have been innocent. All the people living in Israel are like brother, sister, mother, father, son, daughter, etc. Gilad Shalit is a brother, innocent, and had been captured by Hamas.
The support from the Jewish people has been very plentiful. The Jews are freeing 1,000 GUILTY prisoners to obtain 1 Jewish INNOCENT prisoner. The Jews country, Israel, is a very different country then others: When a different person from a different country is captured, it’s not published in the news as much as it was for Gilad Shalit.
I believe that the parents of Gilad Shalit (Aviva and Noam Shalit) have not stopped fighting or protesting from the day he was captured, and to about 5 years later, from when he was released today.
This shows great support from AVIVA
And NOAM SHALIT, MOREOVER
The REST OF ISRAEL.
Melanie Asherian • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:16 pm
I am thrilled and so thankful that Gilad Shalit is back! He was held captive since 2006 by Hamas has finally been set free. Israel has tried and continued trying to get their soldier back because they believe that each of their soldiers return home, and they wont and didnt give up until they got that to happen. They feel that as it is the soldiers duty to serve and fight for Israel, it is their duty and responsibility to have each soldier return home. I believe that he is known because he represents hope.
However, while we are all thankful that Gilad is back, the deal was made that Israel has to release 1,027 of the Palestinian prisoners. So, it is bitter sweet. The fact that we have to release all of these Palestinian prisoners worries us. They did not do their full time, and they were put in for killing people. We are not convinced that they will stop killing people and many of the prisoners will. It is scary, frightening, and sad to think that many Israeli lives could be taken away. So the lingering question that people might ask is was the exchange worth it? Even though Israel managed to save the precious life of 1 Israeli soldier, we might loose a lot more because of all the Palestinians that were let free. Additionally, now that Hamas knows what Israel will do to save their soldiers, they will probably take advantage of Israel and kidnap even more soldiers. Hopefully not.
Chanel Broshinsky • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:12 pm
We have waited for this moment for 5 years, for Gilad Shalit to finally arrive home safely and see sunlight. people, and most importantly, his family. Even though the decision is clear: we want Gilad home, at times I feel that this is a bad decision and is risking many lives of Israeli people. However, this shows how connected Israel is to each soldier and will do anything and take great risks to bring the soldiers home. It makes me proud to be a part of Israel and the Jewish people, knowing that they will do anything to protect one of their people. We can worry about the terrorists tomorrow, but just for today all we need to do is focus on Gilad Shalit and this huge event in history.
Anina Dassa • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:08 pm
Many would agree that the releasing Gilad Shalit would be considered a joyous occasion and a positive thing. However, there are many who don’t know whether the freeing of Gilad should be celebrated, or dreaded.The fact that Israel had released 1027 terrorists back into the world is is a very controversial issue that is brought up constantly. Of course people are ecstatic by Gilad’s return. I personally have not developed an opinion on the subject. I feel that Hamas would have an advantage towards us knowing that Israel would give up about 1000 terrorists for the life of one person.On the other side of the situation, the people of Israel all think the same thing, ” what if this had been my child.” Most people would be torn on the subject because it is not an easy thing to grasp. Is the life of one Israeli soldier really worth the freedom of 1027 terrorists?
Elianna Wasserman • Oct 18, 2011 at 6:48 pm
All of us can agree on one thing: the exchange of 1,000 terrorists for Gilad Shalit was a complicated decision, but its happened, and it is now time to “think about the shark and the fish” and to find as much peace in our own lives as we possibly can. I know for a fact that no 2 people in this world have the exact same feelings about whether Gilad should have been returned or not, but I don’t necessarily believe that is what we should be focussing all of our attention on. I think we need to answer some simple questions before we can debate any further; What is a life? what does living classify as? I wish I had the answers to such simple yet profound questions but I don’t. I do know that Gilad was living on one simple thing, (one life and one person) which is also what many of us were living off of: HOPE. Hope for a return home, hope for a better life, and most importantly a hope for a better world. Isn’t that what all of us hope for? Hamas may have destroyed his nutrition, part of his physical being, his connection and contact to his friends and family, and his normal life as a young Jewish man. However, one thing they did not destroy was his hope for a better tomorrow. Otherwise, I do not believed he would have survived the harsh treatment he was ‘living’ under. Feeling thrilled with the return of Gilad and or completely frightened for the future are both valid emotions. Nonetheless, In order to truly honor these 5 horrible years Gilad has spent in captivity, we must hope and act for a better tomorrow. To achieve this, each of us must do everything in our power to be good people, doing acts of kindness toward others, and helping the world move away from hatred and terrorism one step at a time.
Shani Erdman • Oct 18, 2011 at 6:42 pm
As happy as I am that I get to live to see the day of my dream and the dream of so many others become a reality, I cannot help but feel a lingering fear. In exchange for the solider Gilad Shalit who was help captive in for over 5 years, Israel is releasing over 1,000 terrorists who have killed and have promised to continue killing. Now that Hamas knows how high the price is that we are willing to pay for our people and how much we value life, many people in Hamas are planning on kidnapping more soliders in order to free more of their fellow terrorists. Also, now that Gilad is free, many people who had family members killed by the imprisoned terrorists are probably furious. I feel so bad for Gilad, who is completely innocent and had to endure such an unimaginable fate. He is probably feeling extremely guilty for everything occurring. Now that we have released one solider, when another is kidnapped the Israeli government is probably going to feel obligated to free him, because they freed Gilad.
On the other hand, I am so proud to belong to a people that will do so much for their people. It is amazing that everyone knows Gilad Shalit’s name, while I do not even know any American soliders held captive.
At moments I think that the government made an unwise decision, but then I think of what Gilad and his family had to endure and I change my mind. I cannot imagine having someone I know taken hostage and I cannot even begin to understand the greif that his family felt and the inexpressible joy that they are feeling now.
I do not know where I stand in the situation, the situation is just so complicated. With that said, I also do have faith that the Israeli government has looked at the situation from many angles and is doing what they truly think is best. I am so relived that Gilad is returned to his loving family where he can finally have his freedom back and a chance at a good life. I hope that after this traumatic experience he can learn how to live a normal and happy life. I wish him all the best.
Maya Haziza • Oct 18, 2011 at 5:27 pm
The freedom of Gilad Shalit has been an amazing lesson to all of us around the world. I believe that
Shalits’s release has proven that Israel, truly values each and every one of its soldiers and has shown the incredible support system that not only Israel, but the world has for Shalit. Israel will continue fighting for its soldiers and will never leave one of them behind. I also believe that a very significant part of his freedom is the participation of his parents. Aviva and Noam Shalit, are the parents of Gilad Shalit, and from the day of his capture have not stopped fighting for their son and had continued to pursue protests and rallies to bring attention to the world and to help their son. Israel and Gilad’s parents have fought for Gilad each step of the way and will continue to.
Ricky Toren • Oct 18, 2011 at 5:08 pm
Last night I was sure Gilad was going to get home and have life lasting emotional issues due to the trauma he faced but I, and the rest of my family, we’re surprised to see that’s right off the helicopter he was able to walk, talk and interact perfectly as if he had never been captured. I know it will take him months or even years to get used to everyday life but I am confident that unlike the other Israelis who were captured and returned he will be cared properly by many therapists and his family in order to have a quick recovery. I grew up saying “When Gilad comes home” as a sign of hope and now that he is home, many of our prayers, hopes and dreams have been fulfilled. Being away from his home, family and friends for 5 years and 4 months he was tortured by Hamas terrorists and now he will be treated like a human being, and a hero.
Welcome back Gilad Shalit, we all missed you.
Tiffany Sabbah • Oct 18, 2011 at 4:52 pm
Gilad Shalit is finally home! After 5 years in captivity, over 1000 Hamas soldiers were freed for his release. So is it time for celebration or worries?
The prisoner exchange shows how important a single life is to Israel. At such a young age Israeli teens are sent to go fight and protect their country, knowing that Israel values their life and will protect them at all costs. The acknowledgement that no single Israeli soldier is alone lets them give themselves fully to the army and is what lets their relatives sleep soundly. Gilad is a son, brother, neighbor and friend and not just an innocent captive boy we saw in the newspaper. Gilad is a person who deserves to one day have the chance of being a husband and father himself. Gilad’s return is a sign of hope and teaches us to never give up.
Although Israel has one life back, we must realize the amount of lives 1000 terrorists can take away. The exchange can possibly lead to more Israeli soldiers being taken hostage and many Israeli lives being taken away. So was the exchange worth it?
Overall, the decision was hard to make but I believe that Israel made the right choice in taking back Gilad Shalit. Terrorism will always exist, regardless of the amount of terrorists free and I have complete faith that Israel will deal wisely with the terrorists they have released. So know I think its time to celebrate Gilad’s return and the courage and determination of all who fought for his release.
Talia Karu • Oct 18, 2011 at 4:41 pm
Gilad Shalit’s homecoming is a true miracle. Even though I usually do not usually hold God responsible for things like this happening, I feel as if there is nobody else who could. Gilad’s homecoming presents a lot of mixed feelings among Israelis, and Am Yisrael, around the world. One one hand, we have been waiting for this day for too long and it is such a relief that Gilad is back home alive and well. On the other hand, the Palestinian prisoners that were released in exchange for Shalit are a potential threat to the State of Israel. When determining whether the Israeli government made the right choice, we need to keep in mind the promise Israel makes to bring back each one of its soldiers, dead or alive. If Israel had not saved Gilad, whether it be by exchanging prisoners, or by bombing his place of captivity, they would’ve broken the trust they have with their citizens. Citizens of Israel would remember this when they debate whether to join the צ.ה.ל. This decision to swap Gilad for 1027 Palestinian prisoners is undeniably illogical. One life simply does not equal 1027 lives, and for that reason, you may think that Israel’s choice was not the best thing to do. However, they made the decision based on emotions and a promise they make to every soldier joining the Israeli army.
I am very apprehensive about Israel’s future, but I am glad that Gilad is alive and back home with his nation.
Arielle Yael • Oct 18, 2011 at 4:12 pm
Israel is a country that differs from every other country in a couple of major ways. It is geographically smaller and its population is smaller. Israeli people are also different. They are in my opinion, the most unified, cohesive people of the world. All Israelis go down similar paths in life, specifically when they are drafted into the army. Every citizen shares in this experience, and army serves as a strong factor in the unification of the Israeli people. Also, Israel, unlike America, does not have a division of Religion and State. Israel upholds itself to their state laws, which are based on the laws of Judaism. And one of the most valued commandments in Judaism is “Bikuach Nefesh”, Saving a Life. And that is what was done today. An important chapter of Gilad Shalit’s life was stolen from him, he was taken away from everything familiar in his life and challenged to carry the weight of an entire country on his shoulders.
When an Israeli is drafted into the army, he or she binds a promise with the country. He or She promises to put his or her life on hold in order to protect the country. And in exchange, the country promises that if (God forbid) anything bad was to happen to him or her, it would do whatever it would take to see that the soldier returns to his or her homeland, dead or alive. Also, in the Tanakh it states, “Kol Yehudim Aravim Zeh La’Zeh”, “All Jewish people are responsible for one another”. If the Israeli government did not take this opportunity to free Gilad, they would be breaking two different promises, a promise to the Israeli people and a promise to God. If the government did not take every measure necessary to free Gilad, it would be breaking its promise to every Israeli who wears the uniform, and every Israeli who would wear the uniform in the future.
It is important for us to realize that one major significance of Gilad’s situation was its “accessibility” to every Israeli. Gilad Shalit could have been anyone. Gilad Shalit could have been you, and it could have been me. Every soldier who put on the uniform had the same probability of finding him or herself in Gilad’s position. And that’s why it doesn’t matter that it was Gilad Shalit. It doesn’t matter that he is the son of Noam and Aviva. It doesn’t matter that he is the brother of Yoel and Hadas. It matters that he is an Israeli, he is a Jew, and he is a member of our Jewish family.
The exchange also sheds light to one of the many major differences between Israel and Hamas. Some people may argue that Israel paid too high of a price for Gilad, but what is the price on life? I didn’t know we had price tags? And what makes one life more valuable than the other? The last time I checked, according to Judaism, every life is infinitely valuable. The most apparent difference between Israel and Hamas after this trade is the high value Israel puts on life. The trade shows that Israel values every single one of its citizens and their contributions to society. Whereas Hamas does not.
I pray for the day when the fish and the shark will finally play hide and go seek together and make peace as Gilad wrote in his story.
Today was not about what was right and what was wrong. There will be a time to analyze every one of the governments decisions. There will be a time to criticize. As Rabbi Shawn put so beautifully this morning after the Town Meeting, “Today I’m going with the shark and the fish”.
Anna Stern • Oct 18, 2011 at 7:14 pm
Arielle,
I completely agree with your beautifully written comment.
I think that on Gliad Shalit’s first day back in his homeland, the fact that this trade was at first crazy should be put on hold. A soldier who has not seen his family in FIVE YEARS is back to where he is supposed to be. He has literally seen the light. Israeli children have a holiday from school. Their country is unified over one man’s journey. Five years ago, I was a naiive child going into fifth grade. A lot has changed since then for the world and for me personally. To all non-believers out there, how much do you think has changed for Gilad Shalit?
Maddy Levine • Oct 18, 2011 at 3:28 pm
Gilad’s release from captivity has provoked not only happiness but worry as well. After five long years Gilad Shalit has finally returned home, and the state of Israel and his family in particular are overjoyed. Though the exchange may lead to more terrorism, more Israeli deaths, today, the heart truly wins out. In this deal, Israel has focused more on the love of its people and the importance of the aspect that each life is “infinitely valuable”. Israel is so unique compared to other countries because I do not know any other country who would release over 1,000 prisoners to rescue 1 innocent man. Yes, the Israeli government took a large risk, but most of us celebrate joy and happiness as a result of Gilad’s return home, since his captivity has brought us together and his release has strengthened our unity and our care for the lives of others. Israel will do anything to protect its people, they took a large risk in releasing over a 1,000 terrorists for one soldier, but they did it with pride and in devotion to their people and country. There are several arguments to both sides, and the Israeli government had an xtremely difficult decision to make regarding this matter, however, I believe that what they decided on was a brave and just decision.
Anna Stern • Oct 18, 2011 at 2:56 pm
I think that Gilad Shalit’s release is a day filled with mixed emotions. Gilad Shalit became a symbol for hope, courage, and the idea that every Israeli is part of a larger community which cares for one another and stands by each other. The Jewish principle, “save a life, you save a world” was literally put into action and something good came out of it. On the other hand, when you save a life, you risk someone else’s. With this release, 1,027 terrorists got the chance to return to their families only to continue to do evil. Hopefully, Israel will deal with them appropriately and send them to where they can do limited harm like Syria and Turkey. In my opinion I believe that in the five years, Israel’s technology and Army strategies have advanced to a point where they can track terrorists and work on keeping themselves safe. Terrorism will always exist no matter who’s released and who comes home. Israel should live with a good feeling that they have one of the most intelligent armies in the world and will do their best to save every human being that they can. “Kol Israel aravim zeh la zeh”. All Israel is responsible for one another. With the release of Gilad Shalit, Israeli mothers, fathers, and the families of Olim Hadashim (new immigrants) can sleep well knowing that their children are protected by the strongest people on earth.
Cole Stern • Oct 18, 2011 at 2:01 pm
Gilad Shalit has finally returned home. So is this time for celebration or for upset?
Our minds warn us that this is a terrible deal that we should not agree to. The off-balanced exchange may lead to more terrorism, which could ripple into more Israeli deaths. We have already seen the result of the exchange of prisoners in 2004, who were responsible of the murders of around 35 Israelis. We also have to keep in mind that this could lead to even more hostage takings and more lopsided deals.
So the mind may be telling us that this is an unjust deal that we should not agree to, however, our hearts feel a little differently about the situation. For this very day, Gilad is not just a soldier, he is Israel’s unknown soldier, purely because of the fact that he is so identifiable. We look at his picture released soon after his capture, with his boyish look and thick glasses, and we ask ourselves, “What could posses a man to take away such an innocent looking person like Gilad?”
So what time is it? Is it time for rejoice or time for sorrow? I have to say that I side with my heart. There is a time for everything, good and bad, and this is the time to celebrate for the long waited return of one of Israel’s most important symbols of hope. And with his safe return, we can breathe a little easier and return to focus on protecting the State of Israel.
sammy zucker • Oct 18, 2011 at 5:25 pm
wow! i really enjoyed your response.
I also feel mixed emotions towards Gilad’s release. On one hand, one man being traded for many terrorists who have killed is a very upsetting idea, especially for those families that have been personally anguished by the murder of one of their own loved ones. On the other hand, he is a Jew, he is our brother, he dedicated himself to the service of our country in order to protect us and our values, and upon those same values we knew that we must bring him home.
Now back to your point of “should we celebrate or not?”, I believe that his return is something extraordinary and instills in me a deep pride for Israel because I know that I have a country that values each individual. That will go to significant costs and lengthy measures to protect every one of them. To know that I have a country that will not lower its values/morals/or ethics even when faced with difficult situations. THAT IS SOMETHING TO CELEBRATE!
And with that I say “welcome home Gilad!” and open my arms and heart to him.
Alex Shamash • Oct 18, 2011 at 9:05 pm
Cole,
I agree with everything you said and you really put into perspective the return of Gilad Shalit. There are so many emotions and feelings about the bargain and his return that many of us don’t know whether to feel happy or sad. Another thing to think about is how Gilad himself is feeling about all of this. There is a huge burden on him because of this negotiation with terrorists and the extremity of the situation. While we maybe could’ve gotten a better deal, this truly demonstrates Israel’s no man left behind policy, but contradicts it’s no negotiation with terrorists policy. The fact that they did so much for one man is noble, but at the same time could hurt Israel as a whole.
Danielle Moalem • Oct 18, 2011 at 1:22 pm
I believe it is great that Gilad is back. Gilad is a symbol of hope and his return proves that Israel really did have a lot of hope and prayed for him to return safely. In addition, this shows that Israel does care for one another and to trade 1,027 terrorists for one soldier to return safely, shows how Israel values life. Welcome back Gilad!
Noah Wallace • Oct 18, 2011 at 12:44 pm
The news of Gilad Shalit’s return is uplifting and calls for celebration. It is incredible how Israel is the only country in the world that demonstrates a sincere concern with each and every life, both of soldiers and civilians. They ignore political standards, and demonstrate a true understanding for how valuable a life is. However, while they in a way demonstrate an ethical set of values, they also, in a different way, demonstrate an unethical set of values. The vicissitudes following the release of Shalit are unpredictable, and potentially devastating. Releasing over a thousand terrorists, hundreds of which had death sentences, is unjust to the families and friends that lost loved ones from the attacks that these terrorists committed. It is also unethical, as they potentially could and probably will commit more terrorist attacks, which will in turn kill several people, while the release of Shalit saves just one. There are compelling arguments to both sides, and the Israeli government had an incredibly difficult decision to make regarding how to handle this dilemma. Overall, I believe they made the correct decision.